The general chapter of the Franciscan Order in Naples elected Michael of Cesena as their minister general in 1316 while he was absent from the proceedings. A scholar of the Sentences of Peter Lombard, he rose to prominence as a theologian and administrator, eventually navigating a volatile period of ecclesiastical tension regarding the definition of absolute evangelical poverty.
Early Career and Theological Leadership
Born in 1270 in Cesena, Michael pursued theological studies in Paris, eventually earning his doctor's degree in 1316. Following his appointment as minister general, he focused on reforming the Franciscan Constitutions. His tenure was marked by the issuance of the document Gravi qua premor in 1316, which sought to clarify regulations concerning property and poverty within the order. These activities coincided with evolving papal efforts to govern the Franciscan commitment to material detachment.
Twenty questions, eight minutes on the clock, and a percentile measured against everyone who has taken it. No sign-up.
Take the IQ test →The Poverty Controversy
The core of the dispute involved whether Christ and the Apostles held individual or collective property. While earlier papal rulings acknowledged that the Holy See held title to goods used by the Franciscans, Pope John XXII issued the bull Ad conditorem canonum in 1322, compelling the order to accept ownership. Michael of Cesena rejected this shift, arguing that the Franciscan commitment to poverty reflected apostolic life. This theological disagreement intensified as the Papal Curia viewed the rejection of ownership as an affront to papal authority.
Exile and Conflict
In 1327, the pope summoned Michael to Avignon. Despite initial delays, Michael arrived but was subsequently forbidden from leaving. Following the chapter at Bologna in 1328, which reelected him in absentia, Michael and allies including William of Ockham fled the papal court. Their attempt to reach Naples failed due to Mediterranean weather, leading them to reach Pisa under the protection of Holy Roman Emperor Louis IV. Michael was eventually excommunicated and formally deposed by the order in 1329.
Final Years
Stripped of his office, Michael spent his remaining years defending his position against papal bulls. He authored several defenses, including Christianæ fidei fundamentum, while residing in exile. In 1331, he was sentenced to perpetual imprisonment by the chapter of Perpignan. He maintained his stance against successive leadership until his death in 1342 in Munich. His remains were interred in the Barfüsserkirche, and his reputation underwent a formal rehabilitation in 1359.
Fast facts
- Born: 1270, Cesena, Italy
- Died: 1342, Munich
- Minister General: 1316-1328
- Education: Paris
- Languages: Latin
- Key Conflict: Pope John XXII
- Rehabilitation Date: 1359
Questions readers ask
Why did the Franciscan Order face conflict with the Pope?
The conflict centered on the theology of evangelical poverty and whether the order was permitted to forgo legal ownership of property.
What happened to Michael of Cesena after his excommunication?
He fled to Pisa, sought the protection of Louis IV, Holy Roman Emperor, and continued writing defenses against the Pope until his death.
